Homes for Sale in Jay, NY

This quaint Adirondack community is home to a robust arts scene. Check out the wooden covered bridge, which was built in 1857 and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Jay boasts several unique local businesses, including a locally owned lumber store, an alpaca shop, and a farmstead creamery.

  • School District: AuSable Valley Central School District
  • Recreation: Hiking, hunting, and fishing in the Jay Mountain Wilderness
  • Arts: Upper Jay Arts Center, Tahawus Center

Featured Properties in Jay and Upper Jay

Woodlands Building Parcel
PRICED TO SELL!! A very nice wooded building lot with gentle grade and access off paved town road in the Woodlands. Perfect for year round or vacation retreat. Water and electric available at site. Vo...
MLS # 157946 | Listed at $5,900
Rustic Whiteface Retreat
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY! Modern rustic home with southern exposure- amazing natural light and heat. Two bedroom, one bath energy efficient cabin just the right size! Easy to maintain yet spacious enough to...
MLS # 155286 | Listed at $159,000
Woodlands Custom Log Getaway
Fabulous 3 bedroom 2 bath Katahdin log home perched on a wooded one acre parcel with filtered views of Whiteface Mountain. This home has approximately 2100 sq. feet of living space with features to in...
MLS # 159404 | Listed at $365,000
Fern Retreat in Jay, NY
Built in 2002, this beautiful 5 bedroom home is in immaculate condition. Tucked away, 100 feet from the road, this wonderful property offers privacy on two building lots. Top quality throughout, with ...
MLS # 158448 | Listed at $285,000